Twenty years after its first publication, H. David Brumble III offers
a revised American Indian Autobiography. He does this in light of two
criticisms. First, critics have challenged his assertion that "it is
possible to separate Indian from editor/amanuensis" in early
preliterate as-told-to autobiographies (vi). Second, Brumble was
accused of not giving enough credence to the preferences of American
Indians in regards to the material they chose to present.